Got Burnout? Click here.

Tony Overbay, LMFT on the Four Pillars of Connected Conversation: Episode 79

Title: Connected Conversations & Nonviolent Communication with Dr. Tony Overbay

  1. Introduction:

    • Hosts: Amanda, Laura, Kendra.
    • Special guest: Tony Overbay, referred to as "Doctor of Narcissism."
  2. Mentions & Promotions:

    • Reminder for listeners to leave a review and comment.
    • Tony Overbay’s podcast: Virtual Couch.
    • Other content from Tony:
      • "Waking Up to Narcissism" podcast and premium version.
      • Podcasts with his children: "The Mind, The Mirror and Me" and "Murder on the Couch."
  3. Discussion Topics:

    • Importance of effective communication for physicians.
    • Tony's concept of the "Pre-pillar" before diving into the "Four Pillars of a Connected Conversation."
    • Introduction to "Nonviolent Communication" by Marshall Rosenberg.
      • Misunderstanding of the title and initial reluctance to explore it.
      • Concept of violence in communication.
      • Key lessons:
        1. Separating observation from judgment.
        2. Connecting actions and requests to specific needs.
        3. Applying the same principles in self-talk.


  • Deep Dive into Nonviolent Communication:

    • Separating observation from judgment:
      • Tony’s example: Son not doing homework leads to a judgment of laziness.
      • Consequences of assuming someone isn’t being honest based on our judgments.
      • Observations and judgments in faith communities and personal relationships.
      • Importance of truly hearing someone's feelings without preconceived judgments.
    • Question for Doctors:
      • Does the concept of separating observation from judgment apply in the medical field?
      • Challenges faced by doctors in having to make quick diagnoses.
      • The variable nature of patient responses and potential biases.
  • Doctors’ Perspective:

    • Importance of separating a medical judgment from moral judgment.
    • Renewal of the DEA certificate and recent training requirements:
      • An increased emphasis on treating people, including those with addiction, with respect.
      • Acknowledgement of past training inadequacies in treating people struggling with addiction.
      • The evolving awareness in the medical community towards compassionate care.
    • Emergency physicians: Need for quick assessment but also understanding the importance of not placing a moral judgment on the patient.
  • Nocebo Effect Discussion:

    • Brief mention of the concept of nocebo effect versus the well-known placebo effect.
    • Importance of patients’ beliefs and mindset on their healing process.
    • The writer passionately delves into the intricate nature of human communication, highlighting the psychological, emotional, and even physical implications of our interactions. Here's a concise summary of the third chunk:

      Understanding and Impact of Words

      • Doctors & Authority Figures: Their words can have unintended consequences. For instance, focusing on a patient's low chances of survival can negatively influence the patient’s mindset. The speaker recalls previous experiences where they might have unintentionally affected patients with their words. They emphasize the importance of being factual yet optimistic.

      • Expectation Effect: The power of one's expectations and beliefs can influence their physical well-being. A book, "The Expectation Effect", and another titled "Mind Over Medicine" by Lisa Rankin provide instances where patients' health changed dramatically based on their beliefs and what they heard. Some patients improved believing in the effectiveness of a treatment, only to worsen after hearing negative news about the treatment.

      • Mind-Body Connection: Western medicine often overlooks the profound connection between the mind and body, a connection that other traditions might address more holistically. The speaker believes that communication has a significant role to play in this connection.

      • Observing & Judging: People are naturally observant and often pass judgments based on their observations. Such judgments are not always accurate, and they can stem from personal biases or experiences. Using an example of people-watching with their son-in-law, the writer illustrates how easily we jump to conclusions based on appearances or preconceived notions.

      • Parent-Child Dynamics: The continuous cycle of misunderstanding and defense between parents and children can be harmful. It leads to preconceived notions and defensive behaviors which prevent genuine communication. Over time, the repeated emotional responses become habitual and override logical responses.

      • Relational Frames: Each individual associates different feelings and meanings to the same word, based on personal experiences and upbringing. This causes challenges in communication, as people might not be understanding each other in the way they intend to.

      • Differentiation: Emphasizes the importance of distinguishing one's thoughts and feelings from another person's. Effective communication requires understanding and empathy.

        1. Judgement vs. Observation: The speaker suggests that separating observation from judgment can lead to self-awareness and growth. Instead of getting defensive when someone offers a critique, they suggest treating it as information and deciding if it has merit.

        2. Knowing oneself: Understanding oneself deeply means recognizing when someone else doesn't truly know who you are. This self-awareness helps in avoiding unproductive arguments.

        3. Four Pillars for Effective Communication:

          • Pillar One: Assume good intentions. This is about giving the benefit of the doubt and believing that most people don't intentionally try to hurt or undermine others. However, if it's challenging to assume good intentions, one should consider that there may be reasons why someone behaves a certain way.
          • Pillar Two: Refrain from telling someone they're wrong, even if you believe they are. This is about avoiding immediate defensive reactions that can derail conversations.
          • Pillar Three: Ask questions before making comments. This is about understanding someone's perspective more deeply before offering an opinion or reaction.
          • Pillar Four: Stay present and lean into the conversation without resorting to a victim mentality.
        4. Using the Four Pillars in a Scenario: Tony uses an example of a husband and wife misunderstanding to illustrate the application of the pillars. By applying the pillars, both parties can feel heard, leading to a more fulfilling resolution.

        5. Turning into the Victim: Tony mentions that often, when faced with criticism or uncomfortable conversations, some people may adopt a victim mentality to divert attention from the issue at hand. This tactic often leaves the original concern unaddressed.

        6. Here's how to apply the teachings in personal relationships:

          1. Practice Active Listening: When your partner speaks, make sure to give them your undivided attention. Don't interrupt, make judgments, or try to find solutions immediately. Instead, try to understand their perspective.

          2. Use "I" Statements: Instead of pointing fingers or playing the blame game, express your feelings using "I" statements. This reduces defensiveness and makes the conversation more about understanding each other rather than arguing.

          3. Ask Open-Ended Questions: Instead of asking yes or no questions, ask questions that make the other person think and express themselves. This can lead to a deeper understanding.

          4. Validate: Even if you don't agree, it's crucial to validate your partner's feelings and experiences. Just acknowledging that their feelings are valid can go a long way in building trust and understanding.

          5. Avoid Assuming: Instead of assuming you know what your partner feels or thinks, ask them. This prevents misunderstandings and unnecessary conflicts.

          6. Self-awareness and Growth: It's essential to be self-aware and be willing to grow. If you notice patterns in your behavior that might be contributing to conflicts, be open to changing and evolving.

          7. Seek Help if Needed: Sometimes, it might be beneficial to seek couples therapy or counseling to navigate complex issues.

          8. Patience: Remember that change doesn't happen overnight. Be patient with yourself and your partner. Celebrate the small victories and understand that both of you are learning and growing.

          In the end, the key is mutual respect, understanding, and a genuine desire to understand each other. If both parties are willing, applying these teachings can significantly improve the quality of personal relationships.

      • Tony's approach is a methodical way to handle conversations that could potentially turn confrontational. By implementing these pillars, people can navigate tough conversations in a way that promotes understanding and connection rather than conflict.

    • Join us for our free webinar, "What's the ICD-10 Code for Injury Sustained in a Dumpster Fire?" Wednesday, September 27th at noon central. Click here save your spot!
    • Revitalize Networking Event at ACEP: Click here to reserve your spot: