What's Wellness 911?

Abstract

Physician suffering in emergency medicine is not simply the product of a difficult job, it is compounded by resistance to the inherent pain of that job. Drawing on Buddhist principles and the work of self-compassion researcher Kristin Neff, this article presents a deceptively simple framework: Pain × Resistance = Suffering. Through a first-person account of burnout, rumination, dread, and numbing behaviors during night shift practice, the authors illustrate how resistance to unavoidable pain, through pre-living feared shifts, ruminating over past decisions, or wishing reality were different, multiplies suffering without reducing pain. The path forward lies not in eliminating pain, which is impossible in emergency medicine, but in moving from resistance toward acceptance, freeing the cognitive and emotional resources currently consumed by fighting what cannot be changed.

Key Findings:

  • The equation Pain × Resistance = Suffering, rooted in Buddhist psychology and applied by self-compassion researcher Kristin Neff, offers emergency physicians a precise framework for understanding why suffering in medicine often exceeds what the job itself demands.
  • Resistance to pain takes predictable forms in physicians: pre-living feared shifts through anticipatory dread, ruminating over past decisions that cannot be changed, numbing behaviors (alcohol, food, late-night screens), and wishing reality, patients, systems, colleagues, were fundamentally different.
  • Pre-living a difficult shift generates the same physiological stress response as the shift itself, meaning physicians who dread work experience its suffering twice: once in anticipation and once in reality, while also missing the present moment where they are actually safe.
  • Rumination over past clinical decisions compounds unavoidable pain with shame and judgment, re-experiencing a finalized situation without the ability to change it; the energy spent in resistance is directly subtracted from resources available for recovery and presence.
  • Moving from resistance to acceptance does not mean indifference or passivity, it means redirecting energy from what cannot be controlled (past decisions, patient behavior, system dysfunction) toward what can be: present-moment well-being, future learning, and personal agency.

Resistance vs. Acceptance: What Each Looks Like in the ED

⚠ RESISTANCE: ADDS SUFFERING

Fighting what cannot be changed

  • Pre-living feared shifts through anticipatory dread
  • Ruminating over past decisions already finalized
  • Numbing with alcohol, food, or screens after shifts
  • Wishing patients, systems, or colleagues were different
  • "If only" thinking and self-judgment after a bad outcome
✓ ACCEPTANCE: REDUCES SUFFERING

Working with reality as it is

  • Living the shift once, not in advance, not again after
  • Extracting lessons from past events, then releasing them
  • Acknowledging what is within and outside your control
  • Redirecting energy toward present-moment well-being
  • Asking: given reality, what do I want to do now?

"Pain x Resistance = Suffering. Being a human means there will be pain. Wishing reality was somehow different adds to our suffering. My suffering lightens as I move from resistance toward acceptance of pain, and I'm able to use all of that wasted energy for things that are within my control, like my own happiness."

Publication details:

JOURNAL
Emergency Medicine News

VOLUME / ISSUE
Vol. 45, No. 7B

PUBLISHED
July 18, 2023

AUTHORS
Amanda Dinsmore, MD; Laura Cazier, MD; Kendra Morrison, DO

DOI
10.1097/01.EEM.0000946948.21090.f5

PUBLISHER
Wolters Kluwer Health / LWW